Homepage › Forums › RetroPie Project › New to RetroPie? Start Here! › RETROPIE CONTROLLER(S) CONFIG › Reply To: RETROPIE CONTROLLER(S) CONFIG
You can set the first one, power down, unplug that one, then plug the next controller in and ES will set that one for RetroArch as well.
Or you can use the RetroPie-Setup script as you have done before, as that will still work.